Understanding Money Shame: What It Is, Why We Feel It, and How to Overcome It
Money is a topic that most of us deal with daily, but it is often shrouded in secrecy and anxiety. One emotion that frequently surfaces in conversations around personal finance is money shame. This feeling can have a powerful grip, influencing how we perceive ourselves and our financial decisions. Let’s break down what money shame is, why it happens, how it differs from guilt, and—most importantly—what you can do to overcome it.
What is Money Shame?
Image by Unsplash
Money shame is the feeling of embarrassment or inadequacy related to one’s financial situation. It stems from the belief that there is something inherently wrong with us because of how we handle money, how much (or little) we earn, or the debts we owe. This shame is not just about having less money; it can also affect those who are financially well-off but feel guilty for their wealth, lack financial literacy, or are ashamed of past financial mistakes.
A study by the National Endowment for Financial Education (NEFE) found that 70% of Americans report feeling financially stressed, and much of this stress is closely tied to feelings of shame and inadequacy. A survey by FP Canada found that 48% of Canadians feel ashamed of their financial situation, with many reporting feelings of anxiety, stress, and avoidance when it comes to money matters .
The weight of money shame can be paralyzing, leading to avoidance behaviors, like not opening bills, ignoring debt collectors, or feeling reluctant to ask for financial advice.
Why Do We Experience Money Shame?
Cultural Conditioning: Many cultures treat money as a taboo subject, not something to be openly discussed or shared. From a young age, we may internalize messages that tie our self-worth to our net worth. For instance, societal pressures can dictate that success equals wealth, and financial struggles are a personal failure.
Social Media Comparisons: In our hyper-connected world, it's easy to fall into the comparison trap. Seeing others' curated lives on social media—new homes, luxury vacations, or expensive gadgets—can make us feel inferior if we don't measure up financially.
Personal History: Our upbringing and experiences shape our relationship with money. If you were raised in a household where money was always tight or treated as a source of conflict, you might carry that anxiety or shame into adulthood. Likewise, past financial mistakes, like poor investment choices or accumulating debt, can leave a lingering sense of shame.
Lack of Financial Literacy: Not knowing how to manage finances effectively can result in embarrassment. A report from the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada revealed that only 55% of Canadians feel confident in their financial knowledge. This lack of confidence can make people hesitant to seek help, fearing judgment or ridicule.
Money Shame vs. Money Guilt: What’s the Difference?
It’s essential to distinguish between shame and guilt because they are different emotional experiences.
Money Guilt arises from specific actions—like overspending or failing to save for the future. It’s often a helpful emotion because it can prompt us to reflect and make better choices. For example, if you feel guilty about not contributing to your retirement fund, this guilt can motivate you to change your habits.
Money Shame, on the other hand, is a more pervasive feeling. It’s not just about what you did; it’s about who you are. Shame can make you feel that you are fundamentally flawed, reinforcing a negative cycle that keeps you stuck. Unlike guilt, shame is not constructive—it does not motivate positive change but rather causes a downward spiral of avoidance and anxiety.
How to Overcome Money Shame
Talk About It: The first step to overcoming money shame is to talk about it openly. Share your feelings with a trusted friend, family member, or therapist. Talking about money can break the stigma and normalize conversations that help reduce shame.
Educate Yourself: Building financial literacy is a powerful tool against money shame. The more you understand about budgeting, investing, saving, and debt management, the more empowered you will feel. There are many free or low-cost resources available, from online courses to workshops hosted by local financial institutions.
Cut yourself some slack: Understand that everyone makes financial mistakes. Rather than beating yourself up, practice self-compassion. Treat yourself with the same kindness you would offer a friend who is struggling.
Set Realistic Goals: Setting small, achievable financial goals can help build confidence. Start with manageable steps, like creating a budget or setting up an emergency fund. Celebrate these small victories, which can help counterbalance feelings of inadequacy.
Seek Professional Help: If your money shame feels overwhelming, consider speaking to a financial advisor, your bank or a money counselor. A professional can offer non-judgmental guidance and help you create a plan tailored to your situation.
Reframe Your Thoughts: Challenge the beliefs that contribute to your shame. For instance, if you believe, “I’m terrible with money,” reframe it to “I’m learning to manage my money better.” This shift in mindset can make a huge difference in your emotional well-being.
The Bottom Line
Money shame is a common but debilitating feeling that can impact our financial well-being and overall quality of life. By understanding what it is, why it happens, and how to combat it, we can begin to build a healthier relationship with money. Remember, you are not alone—many people experience money shame, and there are practical steps you can take to overcome it. The journey to financial confidence and peace of mind begins with acknowledging your feelings, educating yourself, and seeking support when needed.